By IDG Enterprise

An Xbox gaming tablet would hurt the Windows 8 BYOD strategy

November 06, 2012 1:26 PM
Hide Caption
A family gathers around the iPad for a nice game.
Show Caption

Microsoft spent more than two years and many millions of dollars coming up with a new interface and application model to make Windows 8 tablets competitive with the iPad. But now, if a report today is correct, Microsoft is about to throw a serious wrench in this plan by coming out with a gaming tablet that doesn't run Windows at all.

Tom Warren at The Verge reports that Microsoft is testing a 7-inch Xbox Surface tablet in its Silicon Valley offices. The tablet will reportedly run a specialized form of Windows – just like the Xbox – but will almost certainly not run regular Windows 8 apps. The report lends credence to rumors that cropped up before Microsoft's Surface Tablet debut in Los Angeles last June.

If true, this would undercut the very clever BYOD strategy for Windows 8, which envisions consumers choosing Windows 8 tablets and bringing them to work.

NFL Teams Are Swapping Out Paper Playbooks for iPads. Here’s Why You Should Care.

I've argued before that Windows 8 is not starting out as an enterprise play. Rather, it's the beginning of a years-long attempt to move Windows to where Microsoft thinks the computer market is going – toward mobile always-connected devices with touch screen UIs.

Microsoft actually packed a lot of great enterprise features into Windows 8, including better performance, a new security model that will make Windows much less vulnerable to certain kinds of attacks, and the ability to put a personalized bootable version of Windows 8 on a USB drive, so it can be used from any computer.

But Microsoft forces users to boot into and start applications from the new Windows 8 UI, even if they're on a computer with no touch screen. That UI has no usability benefits for users on non-touchscreen devices, and will require significant user training. The forced march to the new UI means a lot of enterprises will take a "wait and see" approach to the new OS. (I predict Microsoft will actually offer enterprises a boot-to-desktop option in a future version of Windows, but stay tuned.)

Microsoft did this in order to give developers a real incentive to build new-style apps for Windows 8. If it had allowed users to boot into the traditional desktop, that's precisely what a lot of users would have done, and developers might have chosen to ignore the new application model and build for the desktop instead. By ensuring that every single Windows 8 user will be spending significant time in the new UI, Microsoft gives Windows developers a much better reason to build new-style apps.

So the goal with Windows 8 right now is to get consumers to consider it as an alternative to the iPad – a fun tablet with lots of consumer apps that also runs Office and can help you get work done. That's the thinking behind the Windows Surface tablets as well – a single device that works great as a media consumption tablet, and as a work device with a keyboard. If Surface turns out to be a hit, Microsoft's PC partners will have no choice but to put out similar devices.

But the entire idea hinges on tech-savvy consumers choosing a Windows 8 tablet instead of an iPad, then bringing it to work.

Latest Stories
May 25, 2013 11:51 AM

10 shocking things I learned using Google products exclusively

Getting off Apple and going all Google has increased my respect for both companies. I've come to realize that the very best mobile experience right now is built on a foundation of Google services on Apple hardware. I wish only that these two companies could get along better, and that Apple will allow more Google integration on the iPhone.

May 24, 2013 4:14 PM

Excel: Microsoft's best weapon against Tableau and competitors

New data visualization apps for Excel 2013 could help Microsoft hang on to customers looking for better data visualization tools.

May 24, 2013 3:53 PM

Microsoft isn't crazy to think it could sell 25 million Surfaces next year

Surface has been a stiff so far, but Microsoft reportedly has big expectations for its next fiscal year. Here's why the company may not be crazy.

May 24, 2013 10:27 AM

How an internal social network helped one agency fight terrorism

Flickr by UNC-CFC-USFK

The global law enforcement agency needed a secure, global network where crime and terrorist information could be shared among its members. It found an answer with the enterprise social network, tibbr.

May 24, 2013 9:54 AM

IT must act like a fast-moving startup

Brandon Porco, the chief technologist for defense contractor Northrop Grumman, says that IT will have to try lots of different things and move quickly to keep abreast of evolving employee needs. "Google has it very well-patterned: Launch and iterate."

May 24, 2013 8:41 AM

Enough with the silly myth about Apple hating the enterprise

Although Apple is often accused of not being an enterprise company, it's only in the last few years that Apple has abandoned its enterprise-oriented products. The real story may be that Apple's discovered that making enterprise-focused efforts simply don't deliver a huge return on investment.

FOLLOW US
Get CITEworld updates via email, RSS or social media